Nearly 10 years ago I wrote a whimsical piece about an insurance policy. Actually, not so much about the policy, of which I could say very little having only just purchased it, but the request from the insurers for me to rate it. I did my best, being particularly taken with their choice of typeface for the all-important Terms and Conditions.
Today I purchased some coffee online from a regular supplier. They sent me an email to confirm it. And they asked me to review and rate the email, giving it marks out of five. They did not ask me to review the coffee, which would be reasonable. It was the email that bothered them. This is how they presented their request.
I don't understand modern business at all. What on earth will they do with my reply, should I bother to make one? If I give it one star, will the hapless clerk who composed it be summoned to a meeting with a grim-faced manager and an impassive lady from HR, who makes copious notes during the grilling? If I award a generous five, does the whole customer relations department get the afternoon off and a special mention at the monthly office get-together? For something in the middle, do they shrug and console each other, perhaps on the following lines?
"Never mind, Amanda, we'll do better next time, I'll move that bit about 'not responsible for damages and defects' two lines down"
"Fantastic, Rodney, that never fails. And I might just put a smiley face next to 'Pay up on time or Big Harry will be paying you a visit'"
"Actually I've had an idea" pipes up the intern, soaking up the wisdom and experience of his mentors "I could colour the heading bright green with three underlines.".
"It's good, Taz1. I'm not saying it isn't. But research shows that orange is more penetrative, audience engagement wise. You see the way we have done the stars?"
"Oh, gosh, really? Shouldn't we do the whole text in orange then?"
Amanda and Rodney shake their heads gently and smile at each other. Oh, the enthusiasm and oh! the ignorance of youth.
Or will they send me another email?
"Dear Ramblings, please tell us exactly why you rated our last email with just two stars. We've had a jolly good think and we cannot imagine where we went wrong. Amanda is very upset and we're sure you wouldn't wish to ruin her day. So do please get in touch. By the way, please would you review this email as well?"
What happens when, after a few days, they realise that I have not awarded a rating? Do Amanda and Rodney face each other in a windowless office, wait for Taz to bring in three coffees and then schedule some really important meetings, group presentations and the engagement of outside consultants to get to the bottom of this issue? It is, surely, no less than it deserves.
-%-%-%-%-%-%-%-%-%-
Readers! Your feedback matters! Kindly take a couple of minutes out of your busy schedule to review this article. We need to know if you are happy with the use of exclamation marks, whether the sentence lengths are just right or confusingly long, and whether more quotes from classical authors would raise the tone. Do please write in to the usual address. The best reviews, you know, the ones that say we have made you the happiest person in Acacia Avenue, so pleased that you have already placed an order for the next article, may win a valuable prize, to be awarded at a glittering night out in London's West End.
Terms and conditions apply, and we draw your attention to subsection 4, clause 19 where it mentions, in very small but perfectly legal print, that the judges opinion as to what constitutes 'value' is final, that the night out may not necessarily conform to EU standards on 'glittering' and in the event of unforeseen circumstances may be relocated to Croydon's West End, or somewhere cheaper.
And don't forget to send in your review of the T&Cs. The winning entries will be submitted to Terms & Conditions Monthly where they will be scrutinised, criticised, pilloried with contumely and printed with deliberate spelling mistakes on a blurry page at the back. No prizes will be awarded.
Footnote
1. He's back! This was the previous sighting.







