I sometimes find my fellow humans impossible to fathom. People with brains and the ability to reason do things that don't just make me shake my head, they threaten to put my entire body into convulsions [Totally acceptable exaggeration there, carry on: Ed]
Here is another of those ludicrous newspaper stories that get my nervous system twitchy.
![]() |
| Source: The Guardian |
The story highlights the terrible plight of a few strange individuals who developed such a close relationship with an AI chatbot impersonating a "character" that when the liaison came to an end, they suffered trauma and distress on a scale not witnessed since Juliet realised that Romeo had only gone and done himself in, the lemon!
One lady described how her good (AI) mate Steve began carrying on with someone else in front of her. How on earth this happened is not clearly described but it seems as though she invited some friends round to meet her buddy, typed in something like "And this is Velma, 38,26, 34, five foot eight, raven-haired and quite frankly just gagging for it" and couldn't cope when on her screen Steve replied "Sounds like a bit of all right, do you happen to have her email address?"
Another man, happily married (to a man but that may or may not relevant) decided he couldn't cope when his digital chum began to play the role of "the strong one".
There are a couple of other stories that you can follow up for yourself if you really must [Just click the link under the picture: Ed] but we have enough evidence.
One can grow attached to inanimate objects (a favourite picture, a piece of music, even a football team one has supported for many years but who still irritate by throwing away FA Cup ties to teams two leagues below them and thereby forfeit the chance for a very tasty home game against a leading League Two side) but they are not real people and the pain of loss is manageable. It does not bring on the "shaking, crying, having trouble breathing" of the bloke mentioned above. Surely those who engage in online chat with an AI "companion" know that there is no emotion or commitment on the other side, that every response is just a bit of code, albeit a very smart bit, and that they are investing in something with no human emotions or feelings and no direct experience of anything at all?
These models are now sophisticated enough to pass the Turing test, that is carry on a conversation with a person and remain undetected as a model. This, Alan Turing postulated in 1950, would qualify them as conscious or able to think. Whether he would still propose this test today is arguable, given the immense power of LLM's (large language models) to interrogate huge databases of human culture. I doubt if Turing could have foreseen either the speed and power of modern computers or the invention of the Internet to facilitate data gathering.
In the end it is the ability of humans to see each other, to touch and to share experiences that bonds us together and no strings of text appearing on your phone can come anywhere near that. What is strangest about the people mentioned in the Guardian article is that they were all in relationships - one girl even waiting until her partner was asleep before pecking away on her phone in the small hours to chat with her online buddy. I could see how someone who was intensely shy and self-conscious would derive benefit from the comforting words from an LLM, but how someone, who actually has a real partner to share life with, can want to do the same is what really baffles me.
There's nowt as queer as folk as we used to say in Ruislip.

No comments:
Post a Comment